Total shoulder replacement prices

Surgeons who do this often — Total shoulder replacement

Ranked by published Medicare surgical volume. Volume is not a quality rating.

These counts come from Medicare fee-for-service claims (2024). They are a floor, not a total: privately insured and Medicare Advantage cases are not counted, and CMS does not publish a clinician's count when fewer than 11 Medicare patients had the procedure. A surgeon who mostly operates on younger patients can be high-volume and barely appear here. Studies have linked higher surgeon volume with fewer complications for some procedures, though not uniformly — this list is not an outcome measure. Ask any surgeon how many they do per year and what their complication rate is.

Indianapolis metro

  • Brian Badman, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Fishers, IN

    ≥83 Medicare cases

  • Michael Bender, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Carmel, IN

    ≥64 Medicare cases

  • Mark Dillon, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Indianapolis, IN

    ≥38 Medicare cases

  • Stephen Jacobsen, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Carmel, IN

    ≥32 Medicare cases

  • Alex Meyers, M.D.

    Hand Surgery · Carmel, IN

    ≥31 Medicare cases

  • Chad Waits, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Danville, IN

    ≥29 Medicare cases

  • Damion Harris, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · New Castle, IN

    ≥27 Medicare cases

  • Dale Snead, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Carmel, IN

    ≥27 Medicare cases

  • Kyle Ritter, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Danville, IN

    ≥22 Medicare cases

  • Jeffery Soldatis, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Carmel, IN

    ≥22 Medicare cases

  • David Foulk, MD

    Sports Medicine · Indianapolis, IN

    ≥20 Medicare cases

  • Christopher Defalco, M.D.

    Sports Medicine · Indianapolis, IN

    ≥19 Medicare cases

  • Sebastian Peers, M.D.

    Hand Surgery · Carmel, IN

    ≥19 Medicare cases

  • Andrew Combs, M.D.

    Hand Surgery · Westfield, IN

    ≥18 Medicare cases

  • Brandon Horn, DO

    Orthopedic Surgery · Lebanon, IN

    ≥18 Medicare cases

Louisville metro

  • Ryan Krupp, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Louisville, KY

    ≥144 Medicare cases

  • Scott Mcclure, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Louisville, KY

    ≥93 Medicare cases

  • Scott Kuiper, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Louisville, KY

    ≥77 Medicare cases

  • Kristopher Abeln, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · New Albany, IN

    ≥52 Medicare cases

  • Mark Smith, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Louisville, KY

    ≥41 Medicare cases

  • Kevin Harreld, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Louisville, KY

    ≥34 Medicare cases

  • Nyagon Duany, M D

    Orthopedic Surgery · Louisville, KY

    ≥27 Medicare cases

  • Ty Richardson, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Louisville, KY

    ≥26 Medicare cases

  • Nicholas Kenney, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · La Grange, KY

    ≥19 Medicare cases

  • Jeffrey Been, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Elizabethtown, KY

    ≥18 Medicare cases

  • John Blankenship, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Elizabethtown, KY

    ≥17 Medicare cases

  • Joshua Christensen, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Louisville, KY

    ≥17 Medicare cases

  • Ryan Eads, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Louisville, KY

    ≥17 Medicare cases

  • Christoph Fuchs, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Jeffersonville, IN

    ≥17 Medicare cases

  • Marcis Craig, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Elizabethtown, KY

    ≥16 Medicare cases

Cincinnati metro

  • Robert Rolf, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Cincinnati, OH

    ≥81 Medicare cases

  • Raymond Greiwe, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Florence, KY

    ≥77 Medicare cases

  • Paul Favorito, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Cincinnati, OH

    ≥67 Medicare cases

  • Paul Nitz, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Dayton, OH

    ≥53 Medicare cases

  • Brian Grawe, MD

    Sports Medicine · Cincinnati, OH

    ≥47 Medicare cases

  • Brandon Kohrs, D.O.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Crestview Hills, KY

    ≥47 Medicare cases

  • Andrew Razzano, D.O.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Miamisburg, OH

    ≥45 Medicare cases

  • Samer Hasan, M.D., PH.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Crestview Hills, KY

    ≥44 Medicare cases

  • Trevor Wilkes, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Cincinnati, OH

    ≥35 Medicare cases

  • Michael Herbenick, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Dayton, OH

    ≥30 Medicare cases

  • Matthew Hess, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Dayton, OH

    ≥20 Medicare cases

  • Matthew Langenderfer, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Cincinnati, OH

    ≥17 Medicare cases

  • Joseph Scheidler, D.O.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Hamilton, OH

    ≥17 Medicare cases

  • Marc Schneider, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Blue Ash, OH

    ≥17 Medicare cases

  • Krista Migliore, D.O.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Hamilton, OH

    ≥14 Medicare cases

Columbus metro

  • Joseph Mileti, MD

    Sports Medicine · Upper Arlington, OH

    ≥90 Medicare cases

  • Julie Bishop, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Columbus, OH

    ≥78 Medicare cases

  • James Latshaw, MD

    Sports Medicine · Upper Arlington, OH

    ≥66 Medicare cases

  • Jason Hurst, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · New Albany, OH

    ≥55 Medicare cases

  • Scott Stephens, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Westerville, OH

    ≥46 Medicare cases

  • Jeffrey Backes, M.D.

    Sports Medicine · Grove City, OH

    ≥45 Medicare cases

  • Gregory Cvetanovich, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Columbus, OH

    ≥45 Medicare cases

  • Jennifer Kurowicki, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Columbus, OH

    ≥29 Medicare cases

  • Benjamin Szerlip, D.O

    Orthopedic Surgery · Westerville, OH

    ≥28 Medicare cases

  • Ryan Rauck, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Westerville, OH

    ≥23 Medicare cases

  • Kyle Sochacki, MD

    Sports Medicine · Upper Arlington, OH

    ≥23 Medicare cases

  • Thomas Kovack, DO

    Orthopedic Surgery · Dublin, OH

    ≥22 Medicare cases

  • Kenneth Westerheide, M.D.

    Sports Medicine · Gahanna, OH

    ≥22 Medicare cases

  • John Johansen, MD

    Orthopedic Surgery · Gahanna, OH

    ≥19 Medicare cases

  • Mark D'onofrio, M.D.

    Orthopedic Surgery · Lancaster, OH

    ≥17 Medicare cases

Source: CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners — by Provider and Service (2024 claims), retrieved 2026-07-15. Individual clinicians only; NPIs verified against the CMS file — nothing here is estimated or inferred.